‘Unsolved Mysteries’ Volume 3: What Happened to Tiffany Valiante? - Netflix Tudum

  • Deep Dive

    ‘Unsolved Mysteries’ Volume 3: Are You Ready to Solve the ‘Mystery at Mile Marker 45’?

    The Unsolved Mysteries bonus material for the case of Tiffany Valiante, including photos, police reports and more.

    By Steve Helling
    Oct. 18, 2022

On July 12, 2015, outgoing 18-year-old volleyball star Tiffany Valiante was struck by a New Jersey Transit train. Less than a day later, authorities classified her death as a suicide. But Tiffany’s family — and some investigators — believe that she didn’t take her own life, but was instead a victim of foul play. Her shoes and other belongings were found over a mile away from where she was struck. Even more disturbing, family members found an ax with “red markings” near the scene, but it has since been lost. Witnesses have changed their stories and evidence contradicts the official explanation. Now Tiffany’s family has developed their own theory about what happened to their beautiful daughter – they believe she was kidnapped near her home, killed, and then left on the train tracks more than four miles away. What do the official incident reports and evidence photos reveal? Is there another explanation for the death of this promising young woman? 

Tiffany's Father Visits Her Memorial Site | Unsolved Mysteries V3E1

After Tiffany’s death, investigators obtained evidence photos and accident reports that raised more questions than answers. Could vital clues have been overlooked? In the video above, Tiffany’s father shares the memorial that he created in her honor. 

Photos of Tiffany Valiante

See photos of Tiffany just before her death, including what she was wearing on the last night she was seen alive. 

1 / 15
Tiffany was wearing jean shorts on the night she died. The shorts have never been recovered. 
Tiffany was last seen on the family’s security camera as she walked away from the family home at 9:28 p.m. on the night she died. 
Tiffany’s parents, Steve and Dianne Valiante, were photographed by the security camera at 9:29 p.m., just one minute after Tiffany walked down the driveway.
Tiffany enjoying the holidays with family.
Tiffany was a standout volleyball player who was excited about attending college.
An undated shot of Tiffany.
Tiffany at a holiday event.
On the day before she died, Tiffany tweeted that she was feeling “content” with her life. 
This is the location where Tiffany’s body was hit by the train, which was heading East toward Atlantic City. 
A selfie taken from Tiffany’s phone’s camera roll.
Tiffany spending time with her family.
Tiffany with her family.
The shoes Tiffany was wearing the night she died.
Tiffany on the night she died — her shorts have never been found.
Tiffany with her parents.

Roadside clues

See the mysterious clues found by the side of a road, a mile from where Tiffany was hit by the train.

1 / 14
Tiffany was wearing these shoes the night she died. They were found about a mile away from where she was hit by the train.
The exact position of Tiffany’s shoes in the weeds by the side of the road. 
A closer view of Tiffany’s shoes, where they were found.
Tiffany’s left shoe, with a ruler for scale.
This ax was found by Tiffany’s uncle near the point of impact. Police took it into evidence but it was lost, so it’s unclear if it played a role in Tiffany’s death.
Tiffany was wearing this volleyball headband the night she died. It was found next to her shoes, on the side of a road about a mile away from where she was struck by the train. 
This knife was found near the tracks where Tiffany died, but it’s unclear whether it played a role in her death.
Another view of the knife found near the scene.
Another view of the knife found near the scene.
A red iron-on letter A was found near Tiffany’s shoes and headband. It’s unclear whether they are related to her death.
This blue sweatshirt was found near Tiffany’s shoes and headband. Her family doesn’t recognize it, and no one saw her wearing it on the night she died. It’s unclear if it’s connected to Tiffany’s death.
This plastic key tag was found near Tiffany’s shoes and headband. The family speculates that Tiffany may have grabbed the tag as she was struggling to escape from a car on the night she died.
This towel was found near the railroad tracks where Tiffany was killed. Independent testing confirms the presence of human blood from an unknown male. The DNA was unable to be tested properly, because the sample was contaminated.
Tiffany’s uncle placed these handmade markers next to each item of evidence found on the side of the road.

Download additional evidence

See more bonus material for “Mystery at Mile Marker 45” including police reports, the medical examiner’s autopsy report, and a DNA analysis. 

Watch the episode

Watch “Mystery at Mile Marker 45” here.

Got a tip? 

See something that might be important? Go to Unsolved.com and let us know.

Related Tags

All About Unsolved Mysteries

  • Are You Ready to Solve the Mystery of ‘Abducted by a Parent’?
    The ‘Unsolved Mysteries’ bonus material for the abductions of Amina Kandil, Belel Kandil and Aziz Khan.
  • Unsolved Mysteries is back and needs your help cracking four new cases. 
  • Unsolved Mysteries investigates the chilling murder of university student Sigrid Stevenson.
  • Unsolved Mysteries Volume 4, Episode 5 revisits a classic case as sightings continue to pile up.
  • Unsolved Mysteries explores the discovery of a decapitation in rural PA.
  • Unsolved Mysteries Volume 4, Episode 1 offers theories on the identity of the notorious serial killer.
  • Episode 2 of Unsolved Mysteries Volume 4 explores unanswered questions around Amanda Antoni’s death.

Shop Unsolved Mysteries

Go to Netflix Shop

Discover More Deep Dive

  • The Worst Ever franchise is back with deadly tales of the people next door.
  • Are you ready to step back into a world of pure imagination this fall?
  • New series Instadocs answers the burning questions on everyone’s minds.
  • The series features interviews with Becky Hill and witnesses from the 2023 trial. 
  • These celebs are going behind bars to earn their redemption.
  • The lore of Liam, Maggie’s husband, is finally revealed.
  • A new group of couples will soon be playing house with a trial spouse.
  • A father unleashes his secret skills when his daughter goes missing.

Related Videos

  • Paranormal activity, cold cases, and Roswell UFOs.
  • Multiple accounts of The Mothman attacks occurred in this Chicago neighborhood.
  • Unsolved Mysteries follows detectives as they discuss the crime scene.
  • The artist and educator explains her work in “The Severed Head.”
  • After Antoni’s murder in 2015, those close to her keep her legacy alive.
  • Detectives investigated 11 murders between April 1888 and February 1891.
  • Prepare for spine-tingling cases, eerie sightings, and historical horrors.
  • How a trip to Egypt in 2013 impacted his life.

Latest News

  • The Joestars Pony Up For STEEL BALL RUN JoJo's Bizarre Adventure
    Anime character with long blond hair, a wide-brimmed hat, and goggles pointing forward, standing outdoors under a blue sky with scattered clouds.

Popular Now

  • Voicemails for Isabelle dials to the top, and Avatar: The Last Airbender debuts.
  • Stream Voicemails for Isabelle, Office Romance, a new season of Avatar: The Last Airbender, and more.
  • Meet the allies and enemies shaping Aang’s next chapter.
  • Zoë Kravitz, Sadie Sink, and Troy Baker star in a new immersive game experience.